Found: Two pit bulls stolen from Shelter

Published 3:30 pm Monday, February 22, 2016

Update: Feb. 23, 10:25

The two dogs that were stolen from the Humane Society on Friday night have been found and returned.

Shelter worker Ashley White said they received several tips on Monday, and passed them on to investigators at BPS as well as Animal Control officer Jeff Turner.

Email newsletter signup

According to information provided by Public Service Officer Mark Esquivel, one person, Paul Ray Nelson, dob. March 20, 1986, has been arrested and charged with theft by taking and criminal trespass. As it turns out Nelson is the former owner of the gray and white pit bull, which had been picked up by animal control on December 10, 2015. The investigation is ongoing, as one other individual appears to have been involved and assisted in the theft.

White said the dogs are in good shape and they are thankful to everyone in the community who really jumped on this matter and provided information to recover the dogs.




Humane Society seeking two pit bulls stolen from Bainbridge Shelter Friday night


News Writer

Bainbridge Animal Control Officer, Jeff Turner, and Bainbridge Humane Society shelter workers and volunteers were busy Monday morning reviewing Friday evening video footage in an attempt to identify the subjects involved in the theft of two pit bulls from the outdoor cages of the shelter. Turner said based on the video footage he believes the theft occurred between 7 and 8 p.m. Friday night, February 19.

According to an incident report filed with Bainbridge Public Safety, Patrol officer Davina Evans was patrolling Cox Avenue Saturday morning at 8:10 a.m. when she was waived down by Humane Society employee Charles Wesley. Wesley stated he was doing morning rounds when he noticed two blue nose pit bulldogs were missing.


The two cages, both located on the back side of the outdoor area, where the dogs were housed, revealed fresh cuts to the chain link fencing making holes barely large enough to remove the large dogs.

The dogs, a gray and white neutered male known as Douglas, and a female reddish brown and white known as Carmel, had been with the shelter since late November and early December.

Shelter workers had become very attached to the two animals and shelter employee Ashley White stated, “We feel personally violated. That is the way we feel about these dogs here. We strive to keep them safe and protected. It is scary to think this could happen.”

Shelter Director Beth Eck said this incident further accentuates the need for a new shelter facility. “It is necessary to keep some of the larger dogs outside because of crowding,” she said. “It is easy for people to drive by and see the dogs.”

The shelter has experienced two previous animal thefts in 10 years of operation. In both of those cases the thefts were perpetrated by the owners and the dogs were found to be safe.

At this point shelter workers can only speculate on the intentions of the thieves. A primary fear is that they may have been stolen for fighting or baiting purposes.

The health and safety of the dogs is paramount among the shelter workers.

Society Board President Susan Ralph has sent out an appeal. “We are located in the middle of Bill Reynolds Sports facility. There were people across the street when this happened, We want someone to come forward and tell us what they saw.”

The Society is offering a sizeable reward, all donated funds, for information that leads to the identity of those involved and the whereabouts of the dogs.

Anyone with any information is asked to call the Shelter at 229-246-0101.

Submitted photos:

Reward poster for Douglas and Carmel